「既存住宅ストック活用型の居住水準改善システムの提案と可能性の検討-東京23区の高齢者所有住宅ストックを対象として-」に対する討論, (石坂公一, 番水紀行, 近江隆著日本建築学会計画系論文集, 第569号, 169-176, 2003年7月号掲載)

概要

論文の詳細を見る
Concerning the paper, "The possibility of housing condition improvement system through management of existing housing stock", the following 4 points were raised as topics of discussion. 1). In the long run, will "the creation of starting points of the housing chain" by the method of "supplying ultra-small houses" bring about improvements in the housing standard? Will it not invite contrary results? 2). In this paper, elderly people who own their houses, who are generally regarded as wealthy people, are included as targets of public support in housing administration. However, are such people appropriate as recipients of public support? 3). Isn't it more reasonable to start the creation of a housing chain from the private side (wealthy people) rather than the public side? 4). This system, which ignores the free housing-market, is very closed, and requires many artificial and administrative adjustments for the management of systems related to the housing chain, will invite many restrictions to the housing of general users. It may be employed in a limited scale as mentioned in 3), but it is considered to have many negative aspects from the viewpoint of the total welfare production, and to lead to a housing policy that contradicts the public interest.
社団法人日本建築学会の論文
2004-06-30