MuhlpfordtとLehr : 初期の「転形論争」参加者たち(下) : MuhlpfordtとLehrの所説の数学的解釈を巡る論争

概要

論文の詳細を見る
In this paper I would like to introduce and analyse systems of J. Lehr and W. Muhlpfordt. Their mathematical treatments of the problem of coexistence of "the law of labour value" and "the equlization of profit rate"anticipate the later mathematical analyses on "the transformation problem." I would like to try to confirm the significance of their mathematical analyses in the light of tradition of surplus theory. In former part of this paper Marx's 'solution' of the coexistence problem, Engels's assessment on solutions of Lexis and Fireman and Lehr's answer were treated. In this part the system of Muhlpfordt, Howard and King's interpretation of it, and the debate on their interpretation are analized. In conclusion I could say that since Lehr invented the value-price deviation approach, in fact he found "the transformation problem" from value to price, which has been thought the problem that was found by Bortkiewicz, and that Muhlpfordt is an eminent pioneer of input coefficient approach to the production price analysis, using the value-price deviation approach. They are in the tradition of surplus theory from Marx to Bortkiewicz.
長岡工業高等専門学校の論文
1998-03-31