ヒポクラテス『伝統医学論』第20章における反哲学的人間観 : 前5世紀ギリシアの医学思想における人間理解をめぐって
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
The Hippocratic treatise De Vetere Medicina (On Ancient Medicine) has been the focus of attention among classical scholars and historians of medicine. The author attacks in ch. 20 doctors and sophists who base their own medical theories and methods on philosophical anthropology taken from the contemporary natural philosophers. Many attempts have been made to elucidate, as opposed to their philosophical inquiry into human nature, the author's way of understanding it, which still remains unclear. I draw attention to the following points to make it clear that the conceptual framework of the author's medical anthropology is different from theirs. Their philosophical inquiry into human nature has its starting point in fundamental element(s), from which human beings were originally formed. The author focuses on human beings as existent in their present states, whose conditions and functions must be investigated through interrelations between them and their external factors, such as foods and drinks. A medical investigation into the interrelations will give us a scientific idea about human body, whose constituents are taken to be a large number of humors, reacting against some external factors and accordingly making us feel pain. This may presuppose that, in the author's medical anthropology, human body is conceptually demarcated as the physical or material aspect of human being, within which all physiological events depending on external factors and the humors take place. In their philosophical anthropology, however, human body doesn't seem to have been clearly conceptualized as such, because our experience of feeling pain should be judged to take place within the actions of the fundamental element(s), which must be supposed to constitute our cognitive self.
- 2007-06-26
著者
関連論文
- ヒポクラテス『伝統医学論』第20章における反哲学的人間観 : 前5世紀ギリシアの医学思想における人間理解をめぐって
- ヒポクラテスの医療思想--『エピデミアイ』第1巻第11章の論述を手がかりに
- [論文]医学から「心身」の科学へ : ヒポクラテス『神聖病論』第14-17節の解釈を中心に
- 『エピデミアイ』とヒポクラテス医学派 - 古代ギリシア医学論考 -
- 古代ギリシア医学とその思想史的展開 - ヒポクラテス『古来の医術(De Vetere Medicina)』 における「哲学論(フィロソフィアー)」批判をめぐって -
- 内山勝利・木原志乃・國方栄二・三浦要・丸橋裕訳, G.S.カーク・J.E.レイヴン・M.スコフィールド編著, 『ソクラテス以前の哲学者たち』, 京都大学学術出版会, 2006年11月, 630ページ, ISBN4-87698-688-6, 定価5,700円(税別)
- ギリシアの医学思想における「パンゲネシス」の系譜
- ポリュボス『人間本性論』におけるエンペドクレスの影響 : 前5世紀ギリシアの医学思想と同時代の自然哲学についての一考察
- 「自然」(フュシス)と身体 : ポリュボス『人間本性論』における医学的「自然」観
- ギリシア医学と技術(1)
- 「ノモス」と「フユシス」 : 古代ギリシア医学思想における「人間」観の一局面(第47回大会研究発表論文)
- 「技術者」とロゴス : 「古代ギリシア技術」論考
- Elizabeth M. Craik, Hippocrates : Places in Man, Greek Text and Translation with Introduction and Commentary., Pp.xxiii+259, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1998.
- ガレノスと古代ギリシア・ローマ医学史研究の現在 : ガレノス『解剖学論集』の刊行によせて