司法福祉実務からみたラベリング論の批判的検討 (<特集>現代社会と犯罪社会学 : 批判・模索・展望)

スポンサーリンク

概要

• 論文の詳細を見る

• Labeling-theory produced a new approach of the study of deviant behaviors and especially its sociological critique to the authoritative treatment of delinquents by officials has a unique aspect. But this theory so strengthens authoritative elements in the official treatment that it is inclined to function consequently in the direction of tightening authoritative power rather than criticizing it. It seems that this paradoxical point spoils the significance of labeling-theory. Though labeling-theory strengthens the defect of official treatment as to its provision of labels for delinquents, there has been the tradition of avoiding such labels in Japan before this theory was proposed. This tradition is based on Buddhistic thought of pardon, Marxism's theory and Japanese unbelief in former reformatories and it has emphasized the significance of the treatment in the community rather than in a reformatory. But in Japan, this tradition includes problems in itself from the view point of labeling-theory. It has a defect in strengthening labels of delinquents sent to reformatories. The more we try to avoid stamping labels, the more the label which is more selectively stamped becomes strong and overwhelms the delinquent. For these reasons labeling-theory has contradictions in itself and therefore it cannot replace the such preceding theory of deviant behavior as anomie-theory. What is expected hereafter is to refine labeling-theory from causal aspects and to integrate it in to the former theory, especially anomie-theory. At least this reform is necessary for judical welfare - the diagnosis and treatment for the sound upbringing of delinquents.

• 日本犯罪社会学会の論文

著者

• 速水 洋

  日本女子大学

• 速水 洋

  東京家庭裁判所

関連論文

• 非行統制要因としての恥の考察 : 恥は犯罪・非行を抑止するか?
• 宝月 誠 著, 『逸脱論の研究 : レイベリング論から社会的相互作用論へ』, A5判, 330頁, 3,800円, 恒星社厚生閣
• 麦島文夫著「非行の原因」
• 虞犯少年の実態と保護 (虞犯の概念と実態)
• 虞犯少年の実態と保護(虞犯の概念と実態)
• 司法福祉実務からみたラベリング論の批判的検討 (現代社会と犯罪社会学 : 批判・模索・展望)

スポンサーリンク