眠れる獅子(睡獅)と梁啓超
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
The "Sleeping Lion / Awakening Lion" image has figured prominently in the modern discourse on Chinese national identity since the beginning of the 20th century. In recent years, this image has attracted greater attention with the rise of China's international economic and strategic status. The origin and formulation of the "Sleeping Lion" image, however, remain unclear. This study aims to trace the birth of this image and explores the following new facts about it: the term "Sleeping Lion" (shuishi) was coined by Liang Qichao in 1898-1899; Liang used the term to explain the unknown image of Frankenstein's monster which was often used by many Westerners to express the potential menace of a sleeping China. The reason Liang offered such a strange interpretation was that he had read a translated article and commentary by Yan Fu in the Tianjin newspaper Guowen bao (National news), and then construed Frankenstein's monster as a lion-like robot. His unusual interpretation was apparently influenced by his knowledge of the views of Zeng Jize who in 1887 had published an article in English entitled "China, the Sleep and the Awakening". Although some historians have assumed that the "Sleeping Lion" image came from the West through Japan, I do not share this view. First, throughout the entire 19th century, China's image in the West was that of a "dragon", and no articles describing China as a "Sleeping Lion" can be found in any of the major newspapers such as the Times of London or the New York Times ; second, no Japanese newspapers before 1900 used such an expression in reference to China ; third, the Japanese media began to invoke the "Sleeping Lion" image only after the beginning of the 20th century when that image had already become widespread in the Chinese media. For all these reasons, it seems clear that the "Sleeping Lion" image derived from the innocent interpretation by Liang Qichao, which was shared by Chinese intellectuals particularly in the first decade of the 20th century and then circulated throughout the world later. In addition to the formulation of the "Sleeping Lion" image, this essay also tries to clarify the complicated development of the Frankenstein monster image in the late Qing and Republican periods. Translating Frankenstein into Chinese was so difficult at that time in China that some intellectuals, such as Liang Qichao, mistakenly identified Frankenstein's monster with a "Sleeping Lion". This is a good illustration of the complex cross-lingual and cross-cultural phenomenon that took place between two different civilizations at that time.
- 2010-03-25
著者
関連論文
- 眠れる獅子(睡獅)と梁啓超
- 中村哲夫著 移情閣遺聞 : 孫文と呉錦堂(ヒトから人へ)
- 書評 飯島渉・久保亨・村田雄二郎編 シリーズ 二〇世紀中國史
- 韓鋼著・辻康吾編訳, 岩波書店, 『中国共産党史の論争点』, 2008年7月刊, 207頁+25頁, 税込3,150円
- 孫中山生誕130周年記念国際学術シンポジウム「孫文と華僑」大会記
- 国共合作の崩壊とソ連・コミンテルン : いわゆる「スターリンの五月指示」をめぐって
- 近現代中国人物別称データベースBESSHOU : データ項目の再構成
- 近現代中国人物別称データベースBESSHOU
- 受賞講演 山口一郎記念賞を受賞して(附 神戸大学所蔵の孫文の革命パンフレット) (第二回「山口一郎記念賞」)
- 1949年を跨ぐ中国共産党史上の歴史認識問題--いわゆる「西北歴史論争問題」を事例として (特集 再論・1949年前後の中国)
- 合評会 第三パート討論(松居論文) (孫文生誕140周年記念国際学術シンポジウム論文集 『孫文と南方熊楠』合評会 報告集)
- 死後の孫文 - 遺書と紀念週
- 中國共産黨第二回大會について--黨史上の史實は如何に記述されてきたか
- 20世紀初頭中国における"黄帝"熱--排満・肖像・西方起源説 (小特集 中国と日本)
- 対談 「創立史」から「成立史」へ--石川禎浩『中国共産党成立史』をめぐって (特集 中国共産党の八十年)
- 国際交流 楊奎松報告に対する問題提起
- 「第一次国共合作の研究--現代中国を形成した二大勢力の出現」北村稔
- 近代中国の社会と論争(6)社会主義をめぐる論戦
- 近代中国の社会と論争(第5回)東西文明論争
- 山室信一報告「日本の国民国家形成とその思想連鎖」に寄せて (1995年度日本史研究会大会報告批判)
- 施存統と中国共産党〔含 施存統著作繋年目録〕
- 若き日の施存統--中国共産党創立期の「日本小組」を論じてその建党問題におよぶ
- 1910年長沙大搶米の「鎮圧」と電信
- 南京政府時期の技術官僚の形成と発展--近代中国技術者の系譜
- 李大[ショウ]のマルクス主義受容
- 書評 石川禎浩著『革命とナショナリズム 1925-1945』[含 著者コメント]
- 阿南友亮著, 慶應義塾大学出版会, 『中国革命と軍隊-近代広東における党・軍・社会の関係』, 2012年8月刊, 476ページ, 本体6,800円+税
- 書評 飯島渉・久保亨・村田雄二郎編 シリーズ 二〇世紀中國史