小学校教科書に反映された子どもに期待される対処的対人関係 : 「東洋」対「西洋」の対比は妥当か
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
The contents of school texts are very important factors in the socialization of children, and the behaviors displayed by textbook characters are thought to reflect behaviors that each culture regards as suitable. The purpose of this study is to reconsider the interpersonal coping-behavior styles labeled primary and secondary control by Weisz et al. (1984) and depicted in 537 stories in elementary school texts for 6-9 year-old children in two Asian countries (Japan and Taiwan) and two European countries (Germany and Britain). These texts were analyzed for the types of stimuli (others vs. circumstance; positive vs. negative; intentional vs. unintentional) acting on the main characters, and the corresponding coping-behaviors of the main characters (accepting vs. rejecting; active vs. passive; changing vs. non-changing). They were also analyzed for the primary-secondary controls that were constructed as the stimuli and coping-behaviors of the main characters. The findings were as follows. (1) When the stimuli tried to influence to the main characters' requests or behaviors, the Japanese stimuli were portrayed as adding more circumstance stimuli than those in the other three countries, and there was no significant difference between Asian and European texts. (2) The Taiwanese stimuli were portrayed as more supportive than stimuli in the other three countries. There was significant difference between Asian and European texts, but there was also significant difference between Asian countries. (3) There was no significant difference of the stimuli's intention in the four countries. (4) There was no significant difference between the accepting behaviors of the characters toward the supportive stimuli in four countries. (5) The Taiwanese characters were portrayed as behaving more actively toward the supportive stimuli than characters in the other three countries. There was a significant difference between Asian and European behaviors, but there was also a significant difference between Asian countries. (6) There was no significant difference of primary control in the four countries. (7) The Asian characters were portrayed as behaving as secondary control more than the Western ones, but only the Japanese characters show this kind of behavior in more than fifty percent of the cases. These results indicate that the cultural dichotomy, typified as "East" versus "West" should be reconsidered in cross-cultural psychology, in regard to both child development factors and as socio-historical factors within the cultural system.
- 平安女学院大学の論文
- 2001-03-10
著者
関連論文
- 異文化間の移動・協働を可能にする保育実践を考える : 発達の連続性の観点から(自主シンポジウム27)
- 日本の幼稚園・保育所における異文化理解教育体系化の試み : 中国・台湾・韓国・日本の実践事例を手がかりに
- 日本・韓国・中国の小学校教科書に反映された親役割の変化 : 親役割の変化と社会状況との関係
- 日本・中国・台湾の保育者が期待する子ども像 : 子どもの「はずれた」行動への保育者のタイオウに焦点をあてた予備考察
- 小学校教科書に反映された子どもに期待される対処的対人関係 : 「東洋」対「西洋」の対比は妥当か
- 外国人幼児をめぐる言語の有効性と依存性 : 異言語間移動直後に焦点をあてて
- 家族は子どもにとってどのような意味を持っているか : 日本、中国、台湾、韓国における「家族」の理想と現実
- PF01 教科書に描かれた期待される対人関係 : アジアと欧州4カ国の異文化間比較
- PE19 子どもに期待された教師との関係 : 日本、中国、韓国の国語教科暮に描かれた教師像の異文化間比較