The effect of inserted information on analogical reasoning
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
Based on the diagnosticity principle (Tversky, 1977), the systematicity principle (Gentner, 1983) is interpreted as that the deep structure of object has higher diagnostic value than the surface features in analogical reasoning. However, it is not clear that which one of the object's features corresponds to each of the surface and the deep structure in Tversky's research. Another question is whether the diagnostic value of the deep structure is judged higher than that of the surface or not when the diagnostic value of the object's feature is determined by a presentational factor such as the combination of base analogues. In the present paper, we conducted 2 experiments to analyze the effect of presentational factor on the diagnostic value of a given feature using the competitive design in the context of the diagnosticity principle.In experiment 1, 82 subjects read only one judicial precedent and composed a sentence of the target trial. The results supported the validity of the systematicity principle except the subjects' plausibility judgements for their sentence predictions. In experiment 2, 60 subjects read 3 judicial precedents and judged the similarity with the target trial to compose a sentence. A diagnosticity effect was found in the subjects' similarity judgments and also in their importance judgements of the target trial's superficial features. The subjects judged the base-to-target similarity higher with the structurally dissimilar base than the structurally similar base, and their sentence predictions did not match the sentence of the original trial. The results did not fully support the validity of the systematicity principle.
- 日本認知科学会の論文
日本認知科学会 | 論文
- 推論と判断の等確率性仮説 : 思考の対称性とその適応的意味
- 日本語の語順選好は動詞に還元できない文レベルの意味と相関する : 心理実験に基づく日本語の構文研究への提案
- 形容詞と名詞とからなる句の理解の発達過程
- 名詞句と動詞との間の意味的適合度が文の意味表象形成過程に及ぼす効果
- 児童の論理的な読み書き能力を育む思考の相互観察活動 : デジタルペン黒板システムを使用した授業実践から