ファナーリー存在論における＜関係＞:存在の必然性の証明をめぐって
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
In classical discussions on the waḥdat al-wujūd ("Unity of Existence"), absolute existence (al-wujūd al-muṭlaq), that is "existence" itself, is recognized as the one and only reality. Existence is, in this system, identified with God, i.e. the "Necessarily Existent" (wājib al-wujūd), the entire universe being conceived to be self-manifestations of it. However, in the second half of the fourteenth century, this conception of existence was subjected to strong criticism by Sa'd al-Dīn al-Taftāzānī (d. 1389/90). According to this Timurid philosopher-theologian, identifying existence with the Necessarily Existent is impossible, because "existence" itself is merely a secondary intelligible (al-ma'qūl al-thānī) to which nothing in the external world corresponds. Shams al-Dīn Muḥammad ibn Ḥamzah al-Fanārī (d. 1431), with whom we shall deal in this paper, refuted this attack, thereby laying the ontological foundation of waḥdat al-wujūd. The aim of the present study is firstly to cast some light on this "Taftāzānī-Fanārī controversy" from the viewpoint of "Necessity of Existence," which plays a decisive role in Fanārī's whole refutation, and then to elucidate the Ottoman scholar's strategy in demonstrating the identification of existence with the Necessarily Existent. Taftāzānī's criticism revolves around the three themes: 1. classification of existence; 2. existence of the Necessarily Existent and His distance from impurities (qādhūrāt); 3. the Necessarily Existent and unity. In refuting all this criticism, Fanārī posits a concept of "relation" (nisbah). According to Taftāzānī, "existence" is a concept of "being" (mafhūn al-kawn). According to Fanārī, existence thus understood is nothing other than the relation of "existene" itself to the "beings" (kā'ināt), i.e. the created things. Fanārī salvages the identification of "existence" itself with the Necessarily Existent through this equation of what Taftāzānī calls "existence" with the relation of existence.
- 一般社団法人 日本オリエント学会の論文
一般社団法人 日本オリエント学会 | 論文
- 故郷に帰還したゴラーム:サファヴィー朝権力によるグルジア内秩序包摂とその意味
- マルドゥクの「50の名前」の意味について
- クルド系アレヴィー集団にみる聖者崇敬:ババ・マンスール系のオジャク構造と関連付けて
- ヘブル語聖書における「笛」「フルート」の釈義的考察
- 高橋正男著『物語 イスラエルの歴史：アブラハムから中東戦争まで』中央公論新社，2008年，10＋372頁，定価980円＋税