「臓器移植法」施行後第一例(「高知脳死移植」)にみる「患者の人権」と医療報道 : 「プライバシー保護」と「情報公開」。その医学倫理的検証
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
In 1999, the multiple organ transplantation from a heart-beating-donor was reported from Kochi Red Cross Hospital. This was the first case in Japan after the "Organ Gift Act (1997) ". The patient was transported by ambulance to the hospital on Feb. 22, 1999. The Japanese mass media should have been prudent enough not to violate the donor's privacy, such as exact age, address, family, and occupation. But they set their feet on the quiet donor's home town, and took photos and movies. Afterwards, the MHW (Ministry of Health and Welfare) and JOTNW (Japan Organ Transplant Network) forbade the direct access of the media reporters to the hospital and family members, and limited not only the streams of the non-medical information of the patient but also the medical information needed to check the correctness of the transplantation. The immediate disclosure of the medical information is essential to protect the recepients rights. Without this information, patients and families can't check the official announcements of the hospital. Their medical report might be changed by the hosptital to make it consistent with other data or reports. If so, they can know neither the accuracy of the donor's diagnosis nor the accuracy of information used to make the informed consent of the family. The Japanese mass media must make the rational guidelines to distinguish the essential medical information, needed to assess the adequacy of the choice, from non-essential information. I stress the peculiar situation of the case. This transplantation was the first heart-beating donation case in Japan except the very doubtful heart transplantation case by Wada in 1968. I think first that the donor's family must have a very strong will for the correct donation and transplantation. It is their honorable obligation to disclose enough medical data to make the medical staff protect the donor's patient rights.
- 日本医学哲学・倫理学会の論文
- 2000-12-15
著者
関連論文
- 平成八年十二月に沖縄で行われた精神病患者からの腎摘出事件における、『脳死』診断、現病治療の切下げ、本人・家族の提供不同意、コーディネーションに見られる倫理的諸問題
- 現代の委託(アウトソーシング)を考える(討議,第44回研究大会)
- 公立図書館の委託拡大の状況をどう考えるのか : 東京23区の場合(シンポジウム「現代の委託(アウトソーシング)を考える,第44回研究大会)
- 不明本とBDS (特集 図書館の危機管理)
- 「臓器移植法」施行後第一例(「高知脳死移植」)にみる「患者の人権」と医療報道 : 「プライバシー保護」と「情報公開」。その医学倫理的検証