会計写像論に対する言語論的意義の考察(中田信正教授退任記念号)
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
The conclusions reached in this paper can be summarized as follows: (1) As in general linguistics, the linguistic theories of accounting can be classified as the theory of meaning as substance (accepted theory) and the theory of meaning as relation (minority opinion). Many technical terms are used for the key concepts of the theory of meaning as substance. These terms are "mapping," "isomorphism," "mapmaking," "representational faithfulness," "realism," "reflectivity," "correspondence," "causal relations," "fallibilism," and "neutral existence." (2) Fictitious assets and hidden assets are on different levels of language. If the term "hidden assets" is defined as resources unrecorded (or understated) in the balance sheet and also considered as non-language, such a term should be classified as object language. On the other hand, the term "fictitious assets" could be classified as metalanguage. If resources themselves are regarded as language in terms of the theory-ladenness of observation, the term "hidden assets" could be considered as meta-language, in which case the term "fictitious assets" could become meta-meta-language. (3) In Ijiri's concepts, fictitious assets appear to be "surrogates without principals," while hidden assets appear to be "principals without surrogates." However, these assets cannot be fully explained by Ijiri's "imperfect representation" because what appears to be "surrogates without principals" in his theory could occur in "perfect representation" as well. In order to justify the use of Ijiri's theory for both fictitious and hidden assets, the presence or absence of "representation relations" between principals and surrogates should be consciously assumed. (4) In this study, symbolization was conducted of fictitious assets based on symbolic logic. As a result, the presence of fictitious assets indicated a particular negative case referred to as "SoP." According to oppositional inference, the universal affirmative (SaP), which is the foundation for Ijiri's concept of surrogates based on principals, is in contradictory opposition to the particular negative (SoP), which indicates the presence of fictitious assets. Therefore, Ijiri's theory is incapable of offering a logical explanation for the occurrence of fictitious assets as accounting phenomena. (5) Hidden assets were also symbolized according to symbolic logic. As a result, the presence of hidden assets indicated a particular negative case referred to as "PoS." The particular negative (PoS) obtained by transformational inference conducted on the universal affirmative (SaP), the foundation for Ijiri's concept of surrogates based on principals, has a different logical expression compared to the particular negative case (PoS), which indicates the presence of hidden assets. Therefore, Ijiri's theory is incapable of offering a logical explanation for the occurrence of hidden assets as accounting phenomena.
- 桃山学院大学の論文
著者
関連論文
- 営業報告書文化の日米韓比較(鬼塚光政教授追悼号)
- ソシュールと私(鈴木博信教授・林錫璋教授ご退任記念に) (鈴木博信教授林錫璋教授退任記念号)
- 国際会計論における言語帝国主義 (徐龍達教授退任記念号)
- 北東アジア3カ国会計基準の差異とその文化的背景 : 中国・韓国・日本
- 環太平洋圏経営とリレーションシップ・マーケティング(学院創立110周年・大学創立35周年記念号)
- 絵画と会計の言語性について (稲別正晴教授退任記念号)
- 会計における神話とタブー
- 架空資産と簿外資産に関する意味関係論的考察
- 会計写像論に対する言語論的意義の考察(中田信正教授退任記念号)
- 会計の歴史的変遷に関する言語論的考察
- 会計における連辞関係と連合関係
- 形相(フォルム)としての会計(岡崎守男教授退任記念号)
- 企業集団結合財務諸表準則(韓国)
- FASB会計言語観の由来と賛否
- 言語としての会計(第18回桃山学院大学・啓明大学校国際学術セミナー)
- 韓・日財務諸表の比較研究(第17回桃山学院大学・啓明大学校国際学術セミナー)
- 経営分析による日米自動車産業の国際比較 : 本田技研工業株式会社を中心として(共同研究 : Honda of America Manufacturing, Inc. (HAM)の研究)
- 経営学部創設20周年記念号刊行によせて(経営学部創設20周年記念号)
- 情報経済学と会計理論
- 継続的現時会計論における原子論について : チェンバース会計学によせて
- 準備金会計の日韓比較
- 継続的総合償却における費用配分の合理性 : 給付価値の動きにてらして(経営学部創設10周年記念号)
- 現在現金等価額の加法性をめぐる原子論と全体論の論争について : チェンバース=ビックレイ論争の科学哲学的検討
- 単純総合償却における費用配分の合理性 : 給付価値の動きにてらして
- 総合償却論と企業評価論との論理整合性について
- 存在論的会計公準にかんする一考察 : 井尻教授の測定論と公準論をもとに
- 会計測定論への形而上学的接近 : デバインの所説をめぐる一考察