Critical Examination of Reported Energy Intake in Published Dietary Studies of Japanese Subjects Using the Goldberg Cut-Off
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
Although it is now generally acknowledged in Western countries that mismeasurement (under- and overestimation) of dietary intake is a serious problem in studies on diet and health, the validity of dietary assessment methods in Japan has seldom been externally evaluated with objective measures. This study used the Goldberg cut-off to examine whether the energy intake in Japan could be regarded as a measure of habitual energy intake at the group level. Examined here were six published dietary studies in Japan providing 14 subgroups when divided by sex and dietary assessment method. Reported energy intake was expressed as a multiple of basal metabolic rate estimated using equations (EI/BMR). EI/BMR was compared with the subgroup-specific cut-off values representing the lowest and highest values of EI/BMR that could reflect the habitual energy expenditure. Mean EI/BMR was 1.49 (SD=0.09), which was lower than an expected requirement of 1.55. When all 14 subgroups were combined, seven subgroups (50%) had an EI/BMR less than the subgroup-specific lower cut-off value, and one (7%) had the ratio greater than the upper value. The percentages of subgroups having the ratio less than the lower value and greater than the upper value ranged from 43 to 57% and from 0 to 14%, respectively, when subgroups of women (n=8), men (n=6), diet record (n=7), and questionnaire method (n =7) were evaluated separately. These findings suggest that responsible investigators in Japan should critically examine dietary intake data in any study of diet and health.
著者
-
Murakami Kentaro
Department of Clinical Cell Biology, Graduate School of Medicine, Chiba University
-
Murakami Kentaro
Department Of Social And Preventive Epidemiology School Of Public Health The University Of Tokyo
-
Murakami Kentaro
Department Of Social And Preventive Epidemiology School Of Public Health University Of Tokyo
-
Murakami Kentaro
Department Of Clinical Cell Biology Chiba University Graduate School Of Medicine
関連論文
- Dietary Patterns Associated with Functional Constipation among Japanese Women Aged 18 to 20 Years : A Cross-Sectional Study
- PE-403 sLR11, an Enhancer of Intimal Smooth Muscle Cell Migration, Inhibits Fat Accumulation in Mice as a Novel Adipogenesis Regulator(PE068,Obesity/SAS 2 (H),Poster Session (English),The 73rd Annual Scientific Meeting of the Japanese Circulation Society)
- PE-436 Catalytically Inactive Lipoprotein Lipase Overexpression Increases Insulin Sensitivity in Mice(Diabetes/Obesity/Metabolic syndrome-4 (H) PE73,Poster Session (English),The 70th Anniversary Annual Scientific Meeting of the Japanese Circulation Societ
- OJ-198 LR11, an LDL Receptor Family Member, Inhibits Adipocyte Maturation through the Induced Stabilization of Beta-catenin(Diabetes/Obesity/Metabolic syndrome-2 (H) OJ33,Oral Presentation (Japanese),The 70th Anniversary Annual Scientific Meeting of the J
- PJ-478 Deficiency of Toll like receptor 2 ameliorates high fat-induced insulin resistance through the regulation of TNF α expression in visceral fat(Diabetes/Obesity/Metabolic syndrome(12)(H),Poster Session(Japanese),The 72nd Annual Scientific Meeting of
- PJ-683 Cytokine Production is Dependent on the Cell Size of Adipocytes in Mice(Diabetes/Obesity/Metabolic syndrome-12 (H) PJ115,Poster Session (Japanese),The 70th Anniversary Annual Scientific Meeting of the Japanese Circulation Society)
- Estimation of Trans Fatty Acid Intake in Japanese Adults Using 16-Day Diet Records Based on a Food Composition Database Developed for the Japanese Population
- Food Intake and Functional Constipation : A Cross-Sectional Study of 3,835 Japanese Women Aged 18-20 Years
- Effect of Dietary Factors on Incidence of Type 2 Diabetes : A Systematic Review of Cohort Studies
- Neighborhood Restaurant Availability and Frequency of Eating Out in Relation to Dietary Intake in Young Japanese Women
- Disturbed Spatial Learning of Rats After Intraventricular Administration of Transforming Growth Factor-β1
- Critical Examination of Reported Energy Intake in Published Dietary Studies of Japanese Subjects Using the Goldberg Cut-Off
- Neighborhood Restaurant Availability and Frequency of Eating Out in Relation to Dietary Intake in Young Japanese Women
- Comparison of Energy Intakes Estimated by Weighed Dietary Record and Diet History Questionnaire with Total Energy Expenditure Measured by Accelerometer in Young Japanese Women
- Both Comprehensive and Brief Self-Administered Diet History Questionnaires Satisfactorily Rank Nutrient Intakes in Japanese Adults
- Characteristics of Under- and Over-Reporters of Energy Intake among Young Japanese Women
- Self-Reported Rate of Eating and Risk of Overweight in Japanese Children: Ryukyus Child Health Study
- Within- and Between-Individual Variation in Energy and Nutrient Intake in Japanese Adults: Effect of Age and Sex Differences on Group Size and Number of Records Required for Adequate Dietary Assessment
- Within- and Between-Individual Variation in Energy and Nutrient Intake in Japanese Adults : Effect of Age and Sex Differences on Group Size and Number of Records Required for Adequate Dietary Assessment