誓い・神託・来世観 : 前四世紀アテナイにおける宗教の役割
スポンサーリンク
概要
- 論文の詳細を見る
"How and to what extent did religion regulate the acts of the ancient Greeks?" This is the problem the author investigates in this paper. The most useful documents for this investigation are the works of Xenophon and the Attic orators, since they reflect the average religious mentality of the people. Studying these works, the author has found three main factors which strongly regulated the people's behaviour : oaths, oracles (with other divinations), and views about life after death. Concerning each factor he draws the following conclusions. (1)Oaths : Though referring to oaths frequently, the Greeks seem to have doubted divine punishment for perjury. But they could not break their oaths freely, because it caused great blame among the people. Many examples show that they could break them most easily with political intentions. (2)Oracles : While many examples show the people determined their acts according to oracles, some examples deny their blind faith in them. The author examines two examples which show their neglect of oracles (Xen. Hell. V. 4. 47 ; Aisch. III. 130-1 with scholia) and concludes that (i)they were forced to act as if they believed oracles, (ii)they distrusted them in practice, and (iii)those who distrusted them most were politicians and those who distrusted them least were soldiers (the author uses the terms, politicians and soldiers, as ideal types). (3)Views about life after death : The idea that no one can know about life after death may be pointed out as the one which regulate people's behaviour most effectively. Because of this idea they scarcely did or made anything for life after death. This idea also caused them to keep traditional rites. While admitting this idea, they considered the possible picture of life after death, from which the thought that an honourable death was preferable to a disgraceful life appeared. This thought also regulated people's (especially soldiers') acts, but not to a high degree. While admiring this thought, politicians themselves were hardly regulated by it. Through these investigations politicians are found to be unique. Their uniqueness must have been supported by the development of orations. The technique of orations developed to such an extent that orators could say anything including a matter of the gods, which made the intention of gods uncertain and thus weakened religious regulation. Besides this situation, owing to the continual political crises during this century people had to commit themselves to politics to some extent. As a result people came to stand more and more aloof from religious regulation, following the example of politicians.
- 財団法人史学会の論文
- 1988-09-20
財団法人史学会 | 論文
- 高木昭作著『日本近世国家史の研究』, 岩波書店, 一九九〇・七刊, A5, 四一六頁, 四九〇〇円
- 北島万次著『朝鮮日々記・高麗日記-秀吉の朝鮮侵略とその歴史的告発-』
- 脇田修著『近世封建制成立史論-織豊政権の分析 II-』
- イギリス名誉革命体制化における中央と地方 : 「貧民の状態改善協会」の活動一七九六-一八一七年(研究発表)(西洋史部会)
- ジョン・ブリュア著/大久保桂子訳, 『財政=軍事国家の衝撃-戦争・カネ・イギリス国家一六八八-一七八三-』, 名古屋大学出版会, 二〇〇三・七刊, A5, 三一四頁, 四八〇〇円